More than a month has passed since the cotton crop was harvested, but Egyptian farmers are complaining that the crop is still piled up high in their houses and barns.
The government, following a free market approach to agriculture, announced it was not obliged to buy the crop from the farmers. Cotton dealers including spinning and weaving companies have refused to buy the crop, preferring to import cheaper cotton from India and Sudan.
The agricultural cooperatives, affiliated to the state-run Principal Bank for Development and Agriculture (PBDA) say they have no budget to buy the cotton crop.
The result was a huge drop in local cotton prices from LE1,100 ($200) per qantar (4.5 tonnes) last year to LE400 per qantar this season. Cotton is a product which can not be used by farmers, unlike wheat or rice. To be stored, the crop needs large areas which are not available to most farmers.
Farmers, who have usually depended on the government to buy their crop regardless of price or quality, have resorted to the media to threaten that they will not grow cotton any more.
In response to farmers' complaints, Amin Abaza, minister of agriculture and land reclamation announced that the government has allocated LE3 million to the Principal Bank for Development and Agricultural (PBDA) to buy the cotton crop from farmers.
The ministerial decision ordered agricultural cooperatives to buy the cotton from producers, and to pay them 80 per cent of the price immediately. Agricultural cooperatives are currently buying the harvest from farmers but at a low price ranging between LE400 and LE500 per qantar which is unsatisfactory to farmers when compared to last year's price of LE1,100 per qantar.
However, cotton experts believe that the government's intervention is not a sustainable solution to the problem which occurs each time the cotton crop is harvested. Hussein Mohamed Hegazi, chairman of the agricultural production and land reclamation committee at the Shura Council said that the government's decision is only temporary and that cotton marketing is in urgent need of a clear strategy.
Experts say that the annual recurrence of this problem leads to a series of other problems. Hegazi explained: "When cotton prices reached LE1,100 per qantar last year, more farmers wanted to grow cotton last year. Now that prices have dropped, farmers are expected to refrain from growing cotton next year."
The same case applies to wheat, Hegazi added. Due to the increase of international wheat prices this year, more farmers are growing wheat, which will negatively affect other crops.
Nader Noureddin, a professor of agricultural resources at Cairo University said there are many reasons behind the cotton marketing problem. The first is that the Ministry of Agriculture refuses to participate in the cotton marketing process, claiming that the ministry is an authority for production not for marketing. Noureddin added that the Ministry of Industry and Trade permitted importing cotton from different countries such as Sudan and India, so cotton dealers were inclined to import cotton which is less in price and quality than the Egyptian cotton. The result was that local needs of cotton was almost covered by imported cotton. In addition, Egyptian cotton was not sufficiently promoted in international markets, he added.
According to Noureddin, although the World Trade Organisation gives governments the right to protect its local product when it is negatively affected by imports, the government does not take any action to protect the cotton harvest or farmers' rights. "The government should not permit importing cotton unless local production is sold out, in order to protect farmers' rights," says Noureddin.
Moreover, experts are against the cancellation of the Egyptian cotton bourse few months ago, which they say has a clearly negative impact on cotton prices. Noureddin explained that being a strategic product, cotton needs a bourse to stabilise its prices according to international prices and guarantees farmers' rights. "It is unfair that farmers faced big losses this season," Noureddin said, "agricultural policy should be reconsidered in accordance with the international prices of agricultural products."
